Home / Decisions

Case Digest

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

Decisions

Search this page using your browser

If you would like to search this page you can do so using your browsers search function. To open the search all you need to do is hold down the CTRL key and press F on your keyboard. This will open a find window and then you can then use this to type in your search criteria and click 'Find'. This will then take you to the point in the page where that word/Phrase is used.

Decisions issued in January 2010

15190 - Mr G Brown v County Durham PCT – Appeal Against the Conditional Inclusion on the Performers List

Decisions issued in December 2009

15203 - Dr E MacCormaic v Medway PCT – Application for National Disqualification

15199 - Dr W Sticchi v Hastings & Rother PCT – Appeal Against the Removal from the Performers List

15191 - Dr P Lichtorowicz v Gwynedd LHB – Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in November 2009

15197 - Dr R Burman v Enfield PCT - Appeal Against the Refusal to Include on the Performers List

Decisions issued in October 2009

14671 - Dr V Moudgil v Wandsworth PCT – Appeal Against the Removal from the Performers List

15184 - Dr R Shanmugasundaram v Lewisham PCT - Application for National Disqualification

15185 - Dr Apostolopoulous v South Staffordshire PCT - Appeal Against the Refusal to Include on the Performers List

15188 - Mr L Collins v South Gloucestershire PCT - Appeal Against the Refusal to Include on the Performers list

15192 - Dr P Tlusty v Westminster PCT – Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in September 2009

15153 - Dr A Mahmood v Waltham Forest PCT - Application for National Disqualification

15163 – Dr Rahul Thakur v Norfolk PCT – Appeal Against the Removal from the Performers List

15171 – Dr Zamanthangi v Newham PCT – Application for National Disqualification

15172 – Dr M Mitra v Birmingham North East and North PCT – Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in August 2009

15164 – Dr J Newman v Liverpool PCT – Appeal Against the Refusal to Include on the Performers List

Decisions issued in July 2009

15150 – J Oldham Opticians v Manchester Primary Care Trust

15154 – Dr Edward Emmanuel v South Glostershire Primary Care Trust

15159 – Dr D Fleming v East Lancashire PCT – Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in June 2009

14995 – Dr Adlakha v South Birmingham PCT

15101 – Dr R Manley v Derbyshire PCT

14773 – Dr Pawar v East Lancashire PCT

14633 – Dr Piyadasa v Wandsworth PCT

14883 – Dr Robak v Kingston PCT

14945 – Dr Subramanyam v Southampton City PCT

14738 – Dr Akano v Bristol PCT

14696 – Dr Okonkwo v Perterborough PCT

13072 – Costco v Milton Keynes PCT

Decisions issued in March 2009

15048 - Mr J D Atkinson (Chairman), Dr E Walsh-Heggie, Mr M Rayner Between Leeds Primary Care Trust Applicant and Dr E Heinzman

14502 - Dr R Bergauer v Nottingham City PCT – Application for National Disqualification

14742 - Dr P Brompton v North Yorkshire and York PCT – Appeal against Contingent Removal from the Performers List

15057 - Newham Primary Care Trust v Dr Stuart Green – Application For National Disqualification

Decisions issued in April 2009 will be published on the website in the third week of May 2009. Subsequent decisions will be published on the same basis

Decisions issued in February 2009

14912 - Dr C Engelke and Southampton PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

Decisions issued in January 2009

14822 – Dr E Heinzman and Ledds PCT – Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14923 - Dr C Akano and Cardiff LHB - Appeal against removal from the performers list

14931 - Dr A Varga and Hampshire PCT - Appeal against removal from the dental performers list

Decisions issued in January 2008

14109 - DR M VINAYAGAMOORTHY and ENFIELD PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14127 - BIRMINGHAM EAST AND NORTH PCT and DR A S AWAN - Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in February 2008

13833 - DR R BERGAUER and NOTTINGHAM CITY PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13985 - HAMPSHIRE PCT and DR T K AL SAIDI - Apllicationfor National Disqualification

Decisions issued in March 2008

13941 - DR RAM SEWAK PRASAD and MERTHYR TYDFIL LHB - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13942 - DR SATYENDRA NATH JHA and MERTHYR TYDFIL LHB - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14087 - DR PREM PAUL SOOD and NEWHAM PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14149 - NORFOLK PCT and MR S I CRAMP - Application for National Disqualification

14181 - MS S SCOLA and BRISTOL PCT - Appeal against conditional inclusion on the dental Performers List

Decisions issued in April 2008

14224 - DR TILMANN HAACKER and BROMLEY PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

Decisions issued in June 2008

13500 - HEART OF BIRMINGHAM PCT and DR O M PRAKASH ARORA - Application for National Disqualification

13919 - DR ANDREW HELLYAR and SOUTH WEST ESSEX PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14076 - DR DHANRAJ AGGARWAL and SOUTH EAST ESSEX PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14277 - ASCON PROJECTS MGT LTD T/A BELL HALL PHARMACY and CALDERDALE PCT - Appeal against removal from the Pharmaceutical List

14342 - DR E BRINDZAKOVA and NEWCASTLE PCT - Appeal against conditional inclusion on the Performers List

Decisions issued in July 2008

13149 - DR M-R KARLSSON and NORTH DEVON PCT - Appeal against contingent removal from the dental Performers List

13911 - DR S I AHMED and BLACKPOOL PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14125 - PORTSMOTH CITY PCT and DR MOHAMMED-JAFFER DATTU - Application for National Disqualification

14279 - DR P HIRSCHOWITZ and NORTH YORKSHIRE & YORK PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

Decisions issued in August 2008

13072 - COSTCO WHOLSALE UK LIMITED and MILTON KEYNES PCT - FHSAA Panel consideration of National Disqualification

14317 - DR V S CHIANG and BRIGHTON and HOVE PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

14424 - NEWHAM PCT and DR P SOOD - Application for National Disqualification

14497 - DR J MARY and DUDLEY PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

Decisions issued in September 2008

13847 - DR BHARAT BERRY and WEST ESSEX PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14496 - DR S BANERJEE and HULL TEACHING PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14526 - DR WOLFGANG REITER and WOLVERHAMPTON PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14598 - NORTH YORKSHIRE AND YORK PCT and DR HIRSCHOWITZ - Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in October 2008

14164 - DR M CHANDRA and BOLTON PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

14623 - SANDWELL PCT and DR CHRISTOPHER INGOLF BOHLER - Application for National Disqualification

14625 - DR STUART GREEN and NEWHAM PCT- Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14628 - DR MED KIJEWSKI and NEWCASTLE PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

No Decisions were issued in November 2008

Decisions issued in December 2008

14619 - SOUTH EAST ESSEX PCT and DR DHANRAJ AGGARWAL - Application for National Disqualification

14620 - NEATH PORT TALBOT LHB andDR ANDREW GILBEY - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14747 - WOLVERHAMPTON tPCT and DR J GRANDHI - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

14783 - OXFORDSHIRE PCT and DR DAVID OTTERBURN - Application for National Disqualification

14855 - WEST ESSEX PCT and DR BHARAT BERRY - Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in January 2007

13331 - MAREK WOJCIECH SCHUBERT and MORECAMBE BAY PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13361 - DR HASAN SALEM and NOTTINGHAM CITY PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13375 - SALFORD PCT and DR MICHAEL ALLAN MOORE - Application for National Disqualification

13378 - DERWENTSIDE PCT and DR EDWARD J NOWICKI - Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in February 2007

13046 - DR A RAUNIAR and WALTHAM FOREST PCT - Appeal agaisnt contingent removal from the Performers List

13246 - Dr MICHAEL J COOKE and SOUTHAMPTON CITY PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

13438 - CAMBRIDGESHIRE PCT and DR FRANCIS OBENG - Application for National Disqualification

13453 - EAST RIDING OF YORKSHIRE PCT and DR M J F MCKENNA - Application for extension to suspension

13454 - DR S Z AHMAD and HEART OF BIRMINGHAM tPCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13528 - MORECAMBE BAY PCT and MR MAREK SCHUBERT - FHSAA Panel consideration of National Disqualification

Decisions issued in March 2007

13339 - DR M TIBBLE and CITY & HACKNEY PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

13383 - DR R SHUKLA and HARROW PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13423 - DR ABDEL-DAYEM ADEL MOHAMED HASSAN and WESTMINSTER PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

Decisions issued in April 2007

13505 - DR S AKHTAR and LEEDS PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

Decisions issued in May 2007

13408 - MR C BAXTER and SOUTH LEICESTERSHIRE PCT and DUDLEY PCT - Appeals against refusal to include on Optical List

13478 - DR J GRAY and OLDHAM PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13543 - MR J M McGILL and DONCASTER PCT - Appeal against contingent removal from the Pharmaceutical List

13563 - DR B B CHAUDHURI v NEWHAM PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

13624 - BUCKINGHAMSHIRE PCT and MR KEITH DOUGLAS - Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in June 2007

13516 - DR K RUKMANI and SOUTH WEST ESSEX PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

13517 - Dr K RUKMANI and BRIDGTON & HOVE CITY PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13625 - DR I QUANCE and WOLVERHAMPTON PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13650 - SOUTHAMPTON CITY PCT and MS JAYNE OWEN - Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in July 2007

13203 - DR S A KHAN and WANDSWORTH PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

13231 - DR J K GHOSH and NORTHUMBERLAND PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13597 - R J NEWMAN and SWANSEA LOCAL HEALTH BOARD - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

13703 - HARTLEPOOL PCT and DR G ADAMS - Application for National Disqualification

13738 - DR G BALLAS and HAMPSHIRE PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13743 - DR M NELSON-OWEN and CARDIFF LOCAL HEALTH BOARD - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

Decisions issued in August 2007

13613 - MR S CIARKA and HASTINGS AND ROTHER PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

13633 - DR M J DATTU and PORTSMOUTH CITY tPCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13798 - DR DAVID NZEGBULEM and CITY & HACKNEY PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13826 - OLDHAM PCT and DR JOHN F GRAY - FHSAA Panel consideration of National Disqualification

13834 - CUMBRIA PCT and DR MICHAEL STEVENSON- Application for National Disqualification

13840 - WESTMINSTER PCT and DR HTAY KYWE - Application for National Disqualification

13879 - COUNTY DURHAM PCT and DR HOWARD MARTIN - Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in September 2007

13740 - DR V EDEMA-ROSE and TOWER HAMLETS PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13750 - DR S KHADRI and NEWCASTLE PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13854 - DR H KARRENBERG and DARLINGTON PCT - Appeal against conditional inclusion on the Performers List

Decisions issued in October 2007

14020 - FHSAA consideration of National Disqualification

No Decisions were issued in November 2007

Decisions issued in December 2007

13838 - ENFIELD PCT and DR SHANTA DHAR - Application for extension to suspension

13905 - SOMERSET PCT and ASDA OPTICIANS LTD (Taunton) - Appeal against conditional inclusion on the Ophthalmic Performers List

14037 - NEWCASTLE PCT and DR SYED KHADRI - Application for National Disqualification

No Decisions were issued in January 2006

Decisions issued in February 2006

12013 - SHEFFIELD WEST PCT and DR T S SINGH - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICTION

12051 - BILLERICAY,  BRENTWOOD & WICKFORD PCT and DR A W J WALTON - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

12100 - MID HAMPSHIRE PRIMARY CARE TRUST and DR J JACKMAN - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICTION

Decisions issued in March 2006

12166 - DR EMMANUEL AND LEEDS WEST PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REMOVAL FROM THE LIST

Decisions issued in April 2006

11742 - DR ATURU REDDY and REDBRIDGE PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REMOVAL FROM THE LIST

12175 - COSTCO WHOLESALE UK LTD and MILTON KEYNES PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE

12034 - DR ISLAM USMANI and HILLINGDON PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE

12181 - DR DESMIN PEARCE and NORTHAMPTONSHIRE PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REMOVAL FROM THE LIST

Decisions issued in May 2006

12317 - DR R D BRIGGS and NEW FOREST PCT - APPLICATION TO LODGE A LATE APPEAL AGAINST THE PCT DECISION TO REMOVE FROM PERFORMERS LIST

Decisions issued in June 2006

12187 - DR RB FRANKLIN and STAFFORDSHIRE MOORLANDS PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

12198 - MR SCOTT KHADUN and ROWLEY, REGIS & TIPTON PCT - Application for National Disqualification

12332 - DR R BENCI and SEDGEFIELD PCT - Application for National Disqualification

12333 - MS N CASHMAN and MEDWAY PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performer's List

12334 - MS N CASHMAN and MAIDSTONE WEALD PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

12362 - DR KLAUS GODER and NEWCASTLE PCT - Appeal against conditional inclusion on the Performers List

12384 - DR S M KHADRI and NEWCASTLE PCT - Second application for extension to suspension

Decisions issued in July 2006

12216 - DR M ALI and MORECAMBE BAY PCT - Appeal against refusal to include on the Performers List

Decisions issued in August 2006

12359 - DR DEV DUTT and HUDDERSFIELD CENTRAL PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13063 - DR DAVID NEIL DUFFIN and CHESHIRE WEST PCT - Application for National Disqualification

13066 - Dr V SHARMA and NORTH TEES PRIMARY CARE TRUST - Appeal against conditional inclusion on the Performer's List

13073 - MR MICHAEL SEMENUIK and WEST HULL PCT - Application for National Disqualification

Decisions issued in September 2006

13122 - MISS D G MERINO and DUDLEY PCT - Appeal against refusal to include

Decisions issued in October 2006

12243 – DR MA WAHAB and MEDWAY TEACHING PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13192 – DR SHEO N PRASAD and LEEDS NORTH EAST PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13222 - DR D DUTT and HUDDERSFIELD CENTRAL & SOUTH HUDDERSFIELD PCT - Termination of Contract

Decisions issued in November 2006

12363 – DR S J B WHIPPLE and SOUTH WEST OXFORDSHIRE PCT - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13238 – TENDRING PCT and DR NR SHAH - Application for National Disqualification

13421 - FHSAA - Consideration of National Disqualification

13266 - DR W D KAY and HAMPSHIRE PCT (FORMERLY BLACKWATER VALLEY & HART PCT) - Appeal against removal from the Performers List

13296 – ANGLESEY LOCAL HEALTH BOARD and DR ELLIS WYNN OWENS - Application for extension to suspension

Decisions issued in December 2006

13282 - DR M K NANDI and ISLINGTON PCT - Application to extend appeal period to submit substantive appeal

13329 – DR W G SCHNEIDER and SOUTHAMPTON CITY PCT - FHSAA Panel consideration of National Disqualification

13335 – DR A I BOISTELLE and LAMBETH PCT - FHSAA Panel consideration of Removal through bankruptcy

Decisions issued in January 2005

10720 - DR A D CHYC and COLCHESTER PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REMOVAL FROM MEDICAL LIST

11419 - DR R AHMAD and CWENTRAL LIVERPOOL PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON PERFORMERS LIST

11444 - MR BASIL MASHKOUR and EASLING PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON DENTAL LIST

No Decisions were issued in February 2005

Decisions issued in March 2005

11393 - MR M N MACLEOD and EASTERN CHESHIRE PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON DENTAL LIST

11447 - DR RP SINHA and NORTH MANCHESTER PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON PERFORMERS LIST

11483 - DR S SINGH KUMAR and BOLTON PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON PERFORMERS LIST

11523 - DR B B CHAUDHURI and TOWER HAMLETS PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON PERFORMERS LIST

11557 - MR S CRAMP and NORWICH PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON DENTAL LIST

11566 - DR ADE M HASSAN and WESTMINSTER PCT - APPEAL AGSINST REMOVAL FROM PERFORMERS LIST

Decisions issued in April 2005

11607, 11646, 11647 - MR KENNETH HOSGOOD and SOUTHWARK, LEWISHAM, AND LAMBETH PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE

No Decisions were issued in May 2005

Decisions issued in June 2005

11213, 11214, 11215 - MR AMARIQBAL SINGH BAL and SOUTHEND-ON-SEA PRIMARY CARE TRUST, BILLERICAY, BRENTWOOD AND WICKFORD PRIMARY CARE TRUST & BASILDON PRIMARY CARE TRUST - APPEALS AGAINST REMOVALS FROM LIST

11589 - DR ANTHONY DAVID CHYC and COLCHESTER PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

11633 - DR A P JONES and WOLVERHAMPTON CITY PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

Decisions issued in July 2005

11690 - DR K L GUPTA and PRESTON PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REMOVAL FROM LIST

11575 - DR S K GHOSH and GREENWICH TEACHING PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

11631 - MR I PALAHEY and EAST LEICESTERSHIRE PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

Decisions issued in August 2005

11829 - DR S SINHA and SOUTH LEEDS PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REMOVAL FROM LIST

Decisions issued in September 2005

11838 - JONG KEE CHO and SOUTH WEST DORSET PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE

11824 - JONG KEE CHO and SOUTH WEST DORSET PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

Decisions issued in October 2005

11691 - DR NAVEEN KARWAL and MEDWAY TEACHING PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REMOVAL FROM THE LIST

11691 - DR NAVEEN KARWAL and MEDWAY TEACHING PRIMARY CARE TRUST - APPEAL AGAINST REMOVAL FROM THE LIST (supplementary decision)

11691 - DR NAVEEN KARWAL and MEDWAY TEACHING PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

Decisions issued in November 2005

11911/13/14 - MR AMARIQBAL SINGH BAL and SOUTHEND-ON-SEA PCT, BILLERICAY, BRENTWOOD AND WICKFORD PCT and BASILDON PCT - REVIEW/APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

11939 - DR A O OLAYEMI and CITY AND HACKNEY TEACHING PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON PERFORMERS LIST

11968 - DR K N LOCKEY and NORTH TEES PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON PERFORMERS LIST

No Decisions were issued in December 2005

Decisions issued in June 2004

10982, 10983, 10984, 10985, 10986, 10987, 10988, 11004, 11005, 11015 & 11016 – Mr Simon Morelli and South East Oxfordshire PCT, North East Oxfordshire PCT, South West Oxfordshire PCT, Cherwell Vale PCT, Windsor Ascot & Maidenhead PCT, Bracknell PCT, Slough PCT, Newbury & Community PCT, Wokingham PCT, Reading PCT & Oxford PCT – Appeals against refusals to include on ophthalmic lists

11065 - DR MAHMOOD HOSSAIN and EASTERN WAKEFIELD PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON PMS SERVICES LIST

11098 - DR AZHIR MANZUR SARFRAZ and BILLERICAY, BRENTWOOD AND WICKFORD PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON THE SUPPLEMENTARY LIST

11121 - MRS C LE BOSQUET and BROMLEY PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

No Decisions were issued in July 2004

Decisions issued in August 2004

11170 - DR AMEYA DEVA and WALTHAM FOREST PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

11263 - DR AZHIR MANZUR SARFRAZ and FHSAA (and BILLERICAY, BRENTWOOD AND WICKFORD PRIMARY CARE TRUST) - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

No Decisions were issued in September & October 2004

Decisions issued in November 2004

11326 - DR S A HUSAIN and DARLINGTON PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

11350 - DR J K ROY and WARRINGTON PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REMOVAL FROM LIST

11351 - DR K K PAL and SOUTH TYNESIDE PCT - APPEAL AGAINST VARYING OF CONDITIONS IMPOSED ON INCLUSION INTHE PERFORMERS LIST

Decisions issued in December 2004

11402 - DR T S SINGH and SHEFFIELD WEST PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

11403 - DR G D PATEL and LEICESTER CITY WEST PCT - APPLICATION FOR NATIONAL DISQUALIFICATION

11404 - DR K P SAXENA and CENTRAL LIVERPOOL PCT - APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL TO INCLUDE ON PERFORMERS LIST

11417 - DR G ACTIS-BARONE and NORTHAMPTONSHIRE AND HEARTLANDS PCT - APPEAL AGAINST CONTINGENT REMOVAL FROM PERFORMERS LIST